Hearings on the fate of the Garner Road marsh have been pushed off again as developers scramble to bolster their case for “relocating” the wetland to accommodate construction of five warehouses and parking for more than a thousand vehicles. Fifteen days of hearings before the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT) that were supposed to have taken place two months ago are now scheduled to not start until late February 2025.
Pressure is building for a re-examination of provincial legislation that has weakened Conservation Authorities and banned them from providing ecological advice to city governments. Last week the board of the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority (NPCA) unanimously asked the Auditor-General to investigate the changes imposed at the end of last year.
The Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT) hearing respecting the Garner Road Marsh property scheduled to start on October 2 has apparently been postponed. It was to determine the fate of the wetland and farmland at 140 Garner Road East in Ancaster in a scheduled 15-day hearing.
Approving development of nearly 2000 acres of local Greenbelt lands last November was in addition to doing the same for over 5400 acres of rural land in Hamilton three weeks earlier. The owners and developers of those farms, forests and wetlands will also reap financial benefits similar to those who own properties removed from the Greenbelt.
The Integrity Commissioner’s report on Greenbelt removals released last week includes over seventy instances where the person he was questioning did “not recall” significant information. Those not remembering included developers and their agents, politicians and political staff in the provincial government.
There have been dramatic changes in the Hamilton Conservation Authority board with clear echoes of the unsuccessful revolt that took place last year. Two of the revolt leaders now are installed as chair and vice-chair of the environmental oversight agency.
Last month was the hottest May ever for both North and South America. But in what Bill McKibben is calling “the scariest moment yet in the climate saga” we are witnessing a dramatic jump in ocean temperatures.
Public pressure and receptive councillors have made a difference. City council has imposed significant additional conditions on the proposed Dickenson Road warehouse, including requiring the developer to donate to the public the provincially significant wetland, its 30 metre buffer zone, and a woodlot.
The procedural rules for the Ontario Land Tribunal (OLT) hearing on the Garner Road Marsh have now been set for the three-week hearing beginning on October 2. But the changes to provincial legislation in Bill 23 appear to undermine the potential outcome. And the ultimate fate of the Marsh looks bleaker in the wake of revelations on the other side of the continent where the marsh owners control a much larger environmentally damaging project.
Councillors appear fully united in their anger at the provincial Progressive Conservative government’s Bill 23. An initial response decrying the financial impacts of the legislation was approved unanimously. It was accompanied by vows that council will also tackle the environmental, social and democratic implications.
